45 New York Avenue
Shelter Island Heights, NY
$45,000 Rental Price
4 Bedrooms   2.2 Baths

Shelter Island Heights - Summer Perfect

NOw available for Rent for the first time! No details spared in this impeccably renovated Village Classic 4-bedroom spacious home with water views of Chase Creek in the heart of Shelter Island Heights and down the street from shops, restaurants, The Chequit Hotel, Eccentric Bagel, Stars Café, Marie...

NOw available for Rent for the first time! No details spared in this impeccably renovated Village Classic 4-bedroom spacious home with water views of Chase Creek in the heart of Shelter Island Heights and down the street from shops, restaurants, The Chequit Hotel, Eccentric Bagel, Stars Café, Marie Eiffel, Leon 1901, Sunset Beach, Shelter Island Golf Club and more. The first floor graciously flows from the living room with new raised fireplace with custom floating stone seating to the dining room that provides peaceful and commanding water views of Chase Creek both in the morning and at sunset. The new Henrybuilt kitchen, custom Bosch appliances, and hidden wine refrigerator in bar area leads out to the inviting rear Ipe and Mahogany screened-in-porch constructed in 2023 overlooking Shelter Island Golf Club. Freshly installed 8' wide plank white oak floors extend throughout main floor. The ensuite primary bedroom with a recently renovated bathroom and an additional powder room complete the first floor. Re-envisioned railings and stairways lined with custom designed runners lead up to the second floor and lower level. The second floor includes 3 spacious, light-filled bedrooms and a bath while the lower level has walls of ground level windows looking at Chase Creek and gardens, also a perfect option for a future ground level walk-out to the proposed pool. Mature landscaping provides privacy and serenity. Enjoy the benefits of Community Tennis and access to The Shelter Island Heights Beach Club. Kayak or paddle board on the island from one of the many beaches and inlets. Close to both the North Ferry to Greenport and 34 Vineyards on the North Fork and not far from the South Ferry to Sag Harbor, the Hamptons and Ocean Beaches.

Listing Details

New Listing
Shelter Island Heights, NY
Type: Seasonal Rental
Price: $45,000
Approx. square footage: 2,628 sf
Date Listed: 2/20/2025
Web ID: 920003

MD - LD Rental: $70,000
June Rental: $30,000
June/July Rental: $65,000
July Rental: $45,000

Info & Amenities

Type: Single Family
Size: 0.37 acres
Bedrooms: 4
Full Bathrooms: 2
Half Bathrooms: 2.0
Outdoor space: Patio
Fireplaces: 2
Furnished: Yes
Built: 2005
Central Air: Yes
Style: Traditional
Pool: Yes

Listing Agent(s)

Brown Harris Stevens Real Estate Agent Cynthia R. Barrett
Cynthia R. Barrett
Email Cynthia
o: 631-537-4322
c: 917-865-9917
Brown Harris Stevens Real Estate Agent David Tenenbaum
David Tenenbaum
Email David
o: 631-771-5322
c: 347-907-5939

More from these Agents

New Listing
E Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, Hamptons, NY - 3 Bedrooms  
3 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 18
E Brander Pkwy
$35,000*
Shelter Island
3 BR  |  3 BA
Seasonal Availability*

MD - LD Rental: $95,000
June/July Rental: $65,000
July Rental: $35,000
August - LD Rental: $45,000

Cynthia R Barrett  (631) 537-4322
21 Burnetts Cove Road, Water Mill, Hamptons, NY - 3 Bedrooms  
2 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 26
21 Burnetts Cove Road
$52,500*
Water Mill
3 BR  |  2 BA
Seasonal Availability*

Custom Rental: $37,500
June Rental: $25,000
July Rental: $52,500
Two Week Rental: $25,000

David Tenenbaum  (631) 771-5322
Timothy C Burch  (631) 771-5315
Buell Lane, Village Of East Hampton, Hamptons, NY - 4 Bedrooms  
3.5 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 26
Buell Lane
$75,000*
Village Of East Hampton
4 BR  |  3.5 BA
Seasonal Availability*

August - LD Rental: $75,000
Winter Rental: $65,000

David Tenenbaum  (631) 771-5322