By Alexander Powers, BHS Content Team
The Hamptons are known for their stunning beaches and luxurious homes, but the area is also a shopper's paradise, especially when it comes to bespoke gifts and rare finds. From charming mom-and-pop stores to high-end boutiques, each town offers something unique. To help you navigate the best spots for holiday shopping, we’ve tapped into local experts for their insider tips. Here are their favorite places to find the perfect gifts this season:
Bridgehampton
Marders Garden Center: Recommended by Kathleen Mulcahy and Cristina Matos, this rustic garden store transforms into a holiday wonderland during the Christmas season. Nestled in a 19th-century barn, Marders offers everything from yard and landscape items to household décor, Christmas ornaments, and potted floral arrangements. Cristina describes it as “full of charm and very Christmassy” with a pine aroma that immediately puts you in the holiday spirit.
L’Epicuriste: Michael Petersohn’s favorite for gourmet treats, L’Epicuriste is the ideal destination for finding one-of-a-kind culinary gifts for the chefs in your life.
Sag Harbor
The Wharf Shop: If you’re shopping for the little ones, Kathleen Mulcahy suggests The Wharf Shop in Sag Harbor Village. Known for its whimsical toy selection and nostalgic charm, this store is perfect for finding unique gifts that bring joy to children (and the young at heart).
Sylvester & Co.: Michael Petersohn’s go-to for holiday gifts, Sylvester & Co. offers a curated mix of items that range from modern to quirky. It’s the perfect place to find something for everyone on your list.
Thriftknd: For fun throwback clothing, Michael also recommends Thriftknd. Whether you’re shopping for vintage lovers or simply want to add a retro touch to your gift-giving, this store delivers.
East Hampton
The Monogram Shop: Dennis Gallagher recommends this East Hampton gem for personalized gifts with a holiday twist. From monogrammed linens to bespoke accessories, this shop adds a personal touch to your presents.
High-End Boutiques: East Hampton is the place to go for luxury shopping. With stores like Gucci, Prada, and Ralph Lauren, you’ll find high-end options for the fashion-forward people on your list. Michael Petersohn suggests exploring the alleyways to discover hidden gems in smaller shops.
